Costs fears force Lido café owners to end legal battle
New Parliament Hill Fields cafe operators Daisy Green to move in
Friday, 20th November — By Dan Carrier

Emma Fernandez and Patrick Matthews
A LEGAL battle to save the independent café at the Lido on Hampstead Heath has ended after its owners said they could not proceed with a judicial review because the cost of losing would make them homeless.
Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez, who run the café at Parliament Hill Fields Lido, have been locked in a battle with the City of London, which manages the Heath, to save their business after they lost a tender to manage the café they have run for the past 10 years.
But this week it was announced that the café owners have had to reluctantly hoist a white flag of surrender after learning that if they were to proceed with the judicial review and lose, they would be liable for legal costs running into six figures, which would mean they would lose their home and the rest of their businesses.
They have now struck an agreement with the City to leave in February, ending a decade of hard work.
Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez, who run café company Hoxton Beach, discovered a week before Christmas last year that their bid to remain in a business they had built up from scratch had been unsuccessful.
Instead, a catering firm called Daisy Green beat 30 other bids to win the tender. Daisy Green, which runs more than 20 cafés across London, has been awarded the Lido café and the Parliament Hill Fields café, previously run by the D’Auria family.
The Fields café has since been renovated and is open under Daisy Green’s management. Users say the café is a huge success.
Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez took legal advice over the tendering process and put forward a case that the High Court agreed could be considered by a judge.
They claimed that the tendering process had not been transparent and that there had been a conflict of interest. The process saw them lose control of the Lido and the cafés in Highgate Woods and Golders Hill Park. They alleged that the estate agents working for the City to market the cafés had previously found sites for Daisy Green.
The couple told the New Journal: “We firmly believe that the decision – and in particular the process leading up to it – was unlawful.
“Hoxton Beach filed a judicial review claim against the Corporation. Last month, a High Court judge reviewed the claim and granted permission for it to proceed. The judge decided the claim was arguable and should be heard. However, with immense sadness, Hoxton Beach has decided not to pursue it.
“The Corporation is the custodian of Hampstead Heath, Highgate Woods and Queen’s Park. Ultimately we cannot continue operating these cafés without the Corporation’s support. The situation is unsustainable.
“The personal and financial costs have become too great. We have reached the end of the road.
“We are immensely grateful to all of you who have supported us for the best part of a decade. We sincerely wish the best to the new operator and stand ready to work constructively with the Corporation, in a spirit of openness, to secure the best possible outcome for all those affected, including our beloved staff and colleagues.”
A spokesperson for the City said: “Our process was lawful, open, and the only fair and proper way to secure the future of all five cafés.
“Daisy Green and Cosmin Stuparu submitted the strongest proposals and demonstrated the best long-term plans for these important sites.
“It is regrettable that charitable resources have been diverted into legal proceedings.
“Our focus is on delivering an improved café service, with investment in the facilities, affordable options, and all staff paid at least the London Living Wage.”