Demo outside Town Hall calls for schools to be saved from closure risk

Outcome is not 'inevitable', says new council leader

Friday, 20th November — By Richard Osley

71_Uploads – IMG_3796

Demonstrators outside the Town Hall on Monday

HOPES were raised for the campaigns to save four schools from being shut down as Camden’s brand-new council leader declared the closures as “not inevitable”.

On day one in the new job, Labour councillor James Slater said Camden was still “working with the schools affected”.

He was speaking at Monday’s full council meeting, which saw a large demonstration outside. Protesters, including pupils, staff and union members, called for the risk of closures to be removed from La Sainte Union, the secondary school in Highgate Road, and three primaries: St Patrick’s in Kentish Town, St Joseph’s in Covent Garden and St Alban’s in Holborn.

All have suffered a decline in pupil numbers, leading to the consultation programme about their futures.

“We agree closure is not inevitable. Absolutely not,” said Cllr Slater, who was officially confirmed as the new leader at the same meeting.

But he warned that births in Camden had “fallen by approximately 29 per cent since 2015” and that there was around 24 per cent surplus capacity in the borough’s secondary schools.

In a deputation, Liz Wheatley, from Camden Unison, told the meeting: “We know that school funding is a huge issue, but the solution isn’t to underpay people or to close and merge schools.”

The current funding formula from government sees schools paid per-pupil, making it hard to balance the books when the number of applications slides.

“You’re either on the side of the residents and the people who vote for you and those who work for you, or you’re on the side of the people who were saying, this is all we’re going to give you,” Ms Wheatley said.

“You have to pick a side and that fight has to start now.”

Councillor Lorna Jane Russell, the Green group leader, said her group was “extremely concerned”, adding: “Once a school is gone, it is gone.”

Camden has already lost three primary schools amid the crisis over a lack of children.

“This time we want a different outcome and we don’t think that closure should be inevitable,” said Cllr Russell.

Councillor Tom Simon, the Liberal Democrat group leader, called the consultation “little more than a fig leaf covering up Labour’s incompetence”.

He said the “so-called option in the consultation of reducing the published admissions numbers is meaningless when the number of children in a school is so low”.

Last year La Sainte Union, “with its published admission number of 120”, “couldn’t even fill a single form of entry”, he said. “Rewriting the numbers won’t get you any more children.”

A Conservative motion saying “no closure should be treated as inevitable before all reasonable alternatives have been properly examined” was not reached after the meeting ran out of time. Labour had tabled an amendment that would have dropped a proposed six-month review.

The consultation survey remains open until December 14. Options include reducing admission numbers, amalgamation or federation, and closure.

Cabinet members – the 10 most senior Labour councillors at the Town Hall – are due to consider the outcome in February, with a final decision expected in April.

Education chief Councillor Marcus Boyland also said no decisions had been taken and that the outcomes would “come back to the council early in the new year”.

School funding and the council’s wider cuts programme were “different funding streams”, he said, but added that falling rolls had had a “detrimental effect on the quality of education provided and it’s something we need to address”.

HOPES were raised for the campaigns to save four schools from being shut down as Camden’s brand-new council leader declared the closures as “not inevitable”.

On day one in the new job, Labour councillor James Slater said Camden was still “working with the schools affected”.

He was speaking at Monday’s full council meeting, which saw a large demonstration outside. Protesters, including pupils, staff and union members, called for the risk of closures to be removed from La Sainte Union, the secondary school in Highgate Road, and three primaries: St Patrick’s in Kentish Town, St Joseph’s in Covent Garden and St Alban’s in Holborn.

All have suffered a decline in pupil numbers, leading to the consultation programme about their futures.

“We agree closure is not inevitable. Absolutely not,” said Cllr Slater, who was officially confirmed as the new leader at the same meeting.

But he warned that births in Camden had “fallen by approximately 29 per cent since 2015” and that there was around 24 per cent surplus capacity in the borough’s secondary schools.

In a deputation, Liz Wheatley, from Camden Unison, told the meeting: “We know that school funding is a huge issue, but the solution isn’t to underpay people or to close and merge schools.”

The current funding formula from government sees schools paid per-pupil, making it hard to balance the books when the number of applications slides.

“You’re either on the side of the residents and the people who vote for you and those who work for you, or you’re on the side of the people who were saying, this is all we’re going to give you,” Ms Wheatley said.

“You have to pick a side and that fight has to start now.”

Councillor Lorna Jane Russell, the Green group leader, said her group was “extremely concerned”, adding: “Once a school is gone, it is gone.”

Camden has already lost three primary schools amid the crisis over a lack of children.

“This time we want a different outcome and we don’t think that closure should be inevitable,” said Cllr Russell.

Councillor Tom Simon, the Liberal Democrat group leader, called the consultation “little more than a fig leaf covering up Labour’s incompetence”.

He said the “so-called option in the consultation of reducing the published admissions numbers is meaningless when the number of children in a school is so low”.

Last year La Sainte Union, “with its published admission number of 120”, “couldn’t even fill a single form of entry”, he said. “Rewriting the numbers won’t get you any more children.”

A Conservative motion saying “no closure should be treated as inevitable before all reasonable alternatives have been properly examined” was not reached after the meeting ran out of time. Labour had tabled an amendment that would have dropped a proposed six-month review.

The consultation survey remains open until December 14. Options include reducing admission numbers, amalgamation or federation, and closure.

Cabinet members – the 10 most senior Labour councillors at the Town Hall – are due to consider the outcome in February, with a final decision expected in April.

Education chief Councillor Marcus Boyland also said no decisions had been taken and that the outcomes would “come back to the council early in the new year”.

School funding and the council’s wider cuts programme were “different funding streams”, he said, but added that falling rolls had had a “detrimental effect on the quality of education provided and it’s something we need to address”.

Related Articles