Anger at planning process power shift
New rules could see fewer applications discussed by a committee
Friday, 20th November — By Dan Carrier

Camden’s planning chairman Liam Martin-Lane
PLANNING chiefs have been told new national rules on how applications are decided are a “direct attack on democracy”.
Government-ordered “streamlining” means the vast majority of applications will no longer be discussed by elected councillors – and instead can be given the green light by Town Hall officers.
On Thursday, the planning committee heard from outraged civic groups upset that the new process will see unelected staff discuss applications with only the planning committee chair before deciding if they warrant further scrutiny from councillors.
Only cases that have “exceptional circumstances” will go before a committee.
Lucy Rogers, representing the Dartmouth Park Neighbourhood Forum, said in a deputation to the meeting: “We are concerned. It is a step backwards for democracy. It bypasses democratic oversight, denying elected councillors a part in decision-making.”
The government has said the new system would speed up applications, but Ms Rogers added: “The measure assumes that public participation slows down the processing of applications. Monthly statistics show up to 95 per cent of schemes are, in fact, passed.
“Delays have nothing to do with public participation but result from resources and management issues.”
Earlier this year, a committee of councillors threw out a controversial plan to knock down a two-storey 1930s house in Dartmouth Park and replace it with a large block of flats.
Council officers had recommended that it be given consent, leaving the Forum concerned that the new system would have led to a different outcome.
Ms Rogers added: “Residents’ objections are valid if they correctly identify a break with policy. Our objections are usually legitimate and valid, and reinforced by the experience of living near any relevant site: the knowledge of a neighbourhood and its needs, the direct experience of the lack of genuinely affordable housing, and by other specialist knowledge such as conservation and design.
“As things stand, officers spend their time working closely with applicants while ignoring valid objections or proposals from residents. Our comments are seldom allowed to change a scheme, even where it would improve the scheme. We want officers to value residents’ contributions as a positive part of the processes.”
And she called on planning officers to commit to always refer any plans for new data centres to the committee and to ensure that if a councillor calls on a plan to be discussed, this wish would be respected.
Planning chair Labour councillor Liam Martin-Lane told the meeting that there was no point debating the merits of the policy – as it was a case of “after the horse has bolted”. He said: “It took effect on October 31 and it is now the law of the land. We are not here to debate the merits.”
Chief planning officer Bethany Cullen will, with Cllr Martin-Lane, look at applications and decide if they should be heard by the committee.
Ms Cullen told the meeting: “The driver for making these changes is… to streamline and build consistency to how planning committees operate across the country and ensure committee time is spent dealing with the most strategic and complex applications.
“We have decided that under delegated powers schedule two can be looked at by committee under exceptional circumstances and myself and Councillor Martin-Lane will decide the route for determination. Our focus is on the scale of the application and the significance of its impact.”