Defiant protesters – and New Journal battle bus – make their way through the rain to send out a strong message over Whittington sell-off plans

Thursday, 21st March 2013

Thousands of protesters make their way down Holloway Road after setting off from Highbury Corner and heading for the Whittington Hospital and, above, Victoria Wood and her family make their views clear

Published: 21 March, 2013
by TOM FOOT
>>NEW JOURNAL COMMENT: 'After the march, what next? (click here)

LED by the New Journal battle bus, thousands marched through the wind and rain to protest against the Whittington Hospital sell-off on Saturday.

The demonstration, which went from Highbury Corner to the hospital site in Highgate, followed a boardroom decision to sell off public­ly owned buildings, wide­spread closure of beds and axe 570 staff posts as part of a wider plan to shift care out of the hospital and into people’s homes and health centres.

The major surgery at the hospital – made by the board without informing its own governors, patients or MPs – was revealed by the New Journal two months ago. 

The protest reached its climax at a rally outside the hospital’s front doors in Magdala Avenue.

In a series of speeches, the “care in the community” concept was repeatedly criticised while the sale of a huge swathe of NHS land and buildings was pitched as the first step towards outright closure.

The march was attended by a smattering of famous names – including comedian Victoria Wood, Dr Who actor Sylvester McCoy and Only Fools and Horses star Roger Lloyd Pack – backed up by strong support from the unions, political parties, pensioners, disabled groups and students. Many came determined to protect the NHS hospital from what many to believe to be “back-door privatisation”. 

Shirley Franklin, chairwoman of the Defend Whittington Hospital Coalition, organisers of the demonstration, read out a message from a Whittington medical secretary who has already lost her job in the shake-up, following a review by the car parts company Unipart. Mr Lloyd Pack described the Whit­tington as a “damn good hospital that should not be tampered with”, while radiologist Dr Jacky Davis said the hospital could go the same way as the Royal Northern Hospital, now a block of flats on the Holloway Road.

Chavs author and columnist Owen Jones, who lives in Archway, said: “We are not going to get picked off one by one. We have got to link this to something much broader.”

George Binette of Camden Unison spoke about his mother who is charged $20 a day in the United States to pay for one tablet of life-length­ening medi­cine for her term­inal cancer treat­ment that is free in this country on the NHS.

The leader of the Green Party, Natalie Bennett, recalled the closure of the Camden Road Surgery, four years after it was sold to the American health giant United Health, while Whittington Unison rep David Webb called for the board to join the fight for a “fully funded National Health Service”.

Islington North MP Jeremy Corbyn said: “Once you start por­tion­ing off and selling off bits of the health service you end up with us as tenants of the private sector, rather than proud owners of the public realm. That is why we have told this board in no uncertain terms we are opposed to this. It’s not ours to give up or give away.”

Extracts from key speeches made at Whittington rally

The Medical Secretary: "The redundancy process for the medical secretaries has dragged out over many months and has been a kind of mental torture. Suddenly, in a couple of weeks, this process has sped up to meet some unexplained deadline. 

"We have had to make job applications without answers to very important questions. We have been treated appallingly. No one becomes a NHS medical secretary to get rich. We do it because we care about the patients and the NHS as a whole. It was our job to respond to patients’ calls, and support the doctors and nurses with all the essential admin involved in the care of patients. 

"After Unipart came into the hospital, the car firm company, and decided to get rid of us as part of “transforming the patient experience”, we have more or less been forgotten at the Whittington. 

"No one understands how this will work but management insist it will be better for the patients. I would never stand in the way of what is best of patients. 

"Nothing is clear. Information is scant and anxiety among many of the staff is at an extreme level. 

"No one knew anything about the sell off of the buildings until the story broke in the Camden New Journal. 

"The shock that rang through the hospital that day was like an earthquake. Jenner Building is described as an underused admin building but it is largely occupied by doctors, nurses, and therapists. They need offices to plan their care. Where are all of those consultants, nurses, surgeons and dieticians going to do their work when they are not in the clinics? There isn’t enough room in the main building. 

"The Whittington has become a two-headed monster that is at war with itself. Business language and culture is invading the hospital. Medical reps of all types cruise the corridors uninvited. It begs the question: Is the NHS being privatised by the back door, or is it still a public service, and what does it mean for all of you, the patients of the Whittington Hospital?"

Dr Jacky Davis: "Well done for coming. This is our hospital. I have worked here for 30 years. If you want to see what happens when they start cutting the beds – we marched past the Royal Northern Hospital. What is it now? It’s a block of flats. 

"Do we want the Whit to be a block of flats? I don’t think so. Andrew Lansley came in a taxi and stood outside this hospital and said he had protected it. He said no decision about me without me, do you remember that too? 

"Our decision is we don’t want this place closed and we will fight for it. I finish with two of my favourite quotes. Baldrick in Blackadder said: There’s nothing wrong with this idea, except it’s complete bollocks. 

"And here’s a bit of mixed company: Mahatma Gandhi: When the government ignore the people, 'it’s our duty to go out and rebel'.

"We need to go out and rebel."

Roger Lloyd-Pack: "It’s a great turn-out and imagine how many would have come if it had been a decent day. 

"I would have thought many many hundreds more. I share your anger and outrage at what is being proposed. Not least because, for nearly 50 years, I have been paying my NI stamps, like millions of you. 

"Now I am getting to an age – hopefully not – but more likely that I will need a hospital, and I am finding out they want to cut my local hospital. I have been here several times, my wife has been here and my children. It is a damn good hospital and it should not be tampered with. They talk about cutting beds and care in the community. That’s a lot of bollocks. You remember what happened to the mental hospitals 15 years ago. You still see the walking wounded down Kentish Town Road, people who were abandoned by the hospital. Care in the community is an Orwellian phrase, which actually means care less. Can you trust privatised services to look after people in their own homes? Of course you can’t – they are beholden to shareholders. There are some fine looking buildings, good dignified buildings, with good heritage and character. Why tear them down? Use them for health workers so they can afford to live in this area."

Jeremy Corbyn MP: "Once you start portioning off and selling off bits of the health service you end-up with us as tenants of the private sector, rather than proud owners of the public realm. That is why we have told this board in no uncertain terms we are opposed to this. It’s not ours to give up or give away. This hospital was founded by people with a vision. The current board of this hospital sees great merit in selling off a quarter of the site and making 500 jobs redundant in order to transfer care into the community. I do not see this community care as an alternative – I see it as an add-on to what we’ve got."

Frank Dobson MP: "We’ve got all this talk about not enough attention to needs of the elderly when they are in acute wards. 

"But the Whittington is one of the safest hospitals in the whole of the country. It has a few more nurses per patient than the national average. I’m a simple soul. 

"I think there may be some conn­ect­ion bet­ween the fact that there are a few more nurses and they have a bit more time to care for the elderly, the poor, and handicapped patients. To hear they want the level of nursing reduced to some crackpot national average beggars belief. The people who are trying to do this ought to pack in and disappear altogether. Keep up the fight. The Whittington is a brilliant hospital, doing a brilliant job. We know that and we have to make sure everybody else knows that."

Related Articles