AI planning tool had ‘personality' bent on rejecting applications
Battle of the bots: Councils are using AI planning system... to read AI-written responses to design proposals
Friday, 20th November — By Richard Osley

An AI picture of an AI robot scanning AI responses to planning applications
AN artificial intelligence system built to help decide building applications developed a “personality” bent on refusing them, a senior planner has told City Hall.
Mike Kiely, chair of the Planning Officers Society, made the claim at a London Assembly Planning and Regeneration Committee hearing on AI in planning process last month.
He said he had been commissioned to advise “one of the companies that was bidding” for the government’s AI planning contract, an unnamed “California-based company”.
“They processed three or four applications. I think they got the data from [the London boroughs of] Islington and Camden,” he told members.
Recalling that as a team leader he could tell which officer had written a report, he said: “This thing had a personality, and its personality was, ‘I need to find a problem, and when I have found a problem, tick, and therefore I can refuse planning permission.’”
When he raised it, he said, the firm told him: “Oh, it will learn.”
Google Cloud won the £6.9 million contract in February. The resulting tool, PlanAssist, built with Google DeepMind and the firm Faculty, has since been trialled in Camden, Barnet and Dorset. Mr Kiely did not suggest that this was the system he had seen.
At the end of last month, the government said the tool had cut officers’ time on key tasks by 58 per cent and would expand to 15 councils, including Westminster and Lambeth, with every council in England offered it by the end of 2027. Planning officers would remain responsible for reviewing applications and making decisions.
The session came with claims that members of the public and other opponents were flooding council planning departments were AI-composed objections to schemes.
Nissa Shahid, digital lead for town planning at the engineering firm Arup, told the London Assembly’s planning committee that residents opposed to developments were now using AI to do what they once did with template letters. “If people did not like a development, they would all share the same template and all send it in, and flood the planning department with that information. Now they can do it with AI,” she said. “For what is £99 now, you can generate a response. All it is doing is flooding planning departments and making their lives a little bit more difficult.”
She said a submission that looked “really impressive” did not always have “much substance”, adding: “We hear a lot, and all our planning legal sessions are always about how things have come in where half the stuff has been made up… Just because it sounds smart does not mean it necessarily is.” She cited the Greater Cambridge planning service as an example of “the public using AI to basically flood the system with responses”.
Mr Kiely said he had asked ChatGPT and Microsoft’s Copilot to write an objection to a neighbour building “a house at the end of their garden”. “Both of them came back with four, five-page objections that sounded all very good, but complete rubbish,” he said.
He urged objectors not “to bombard the planning department with a load of stuff, because we are just going to put that in an AI machine and it is going to pump out ten bullet points”. Otherwise, he warned, “Planning services will get inundated with stuff. It will be the battle of the AI bots to manage that. That is not helping anyone.”
Independent London Assembly Andrew Boff,said councils had always dealt with petitions and asked: “Is this not like complaining about the weather, though?” – to which Mr Kiely replied: “This all costs money.”
He warned, however, that AI systems could “overpromise and underdeliver”.
Professor Lauren Andres, of UCL’s Bartlett School of Planning, told the hearing that the government’s work was “being done in partnership with Google DeepMind, and in the case of London there are trials in Barnet and Camden”.
She warned that AI could end up “favouring those who have better access to IT and AI skills and who are basically able to influence the algorithm”.
In a Freedom of Information reply last month, Camden said its officers have not used the tool on any live Camden planning applications. It had given the project team about 100 recently decided householder applications “to aid development of the tool”. The council, however, expects to use PlanAssist on live applications in a later “Beta phase”, but said no date had been set.
Chris de Gruben, head of property at the consultancy Artefact, said: “We have built virtual planning committees for every local authority. We know that ‘John’ particularly cares about cycling, while ‘Susan’ really cares about green spaces.” That, he said, lets “any developer” feed in a scheme “and see what the likely result will be”.
He added: “To the point of lots of AI agents coming in and flooding the systems, yes, this will happen. It will 100 per cent happen. I do not think you can stop it. I can build agents that can make up personas that can send out emails and that can submit all of these into the planning systems.”
Benali Hamdache, a Green Assembly Member and Islington councillor, joked that he had “graduated from SimCity on to Cities: Skylines”, but raised concerns about how AI might tackle some applications, pointing to Islington Council’s search for Gypsy, Roma and Traveller sites which he said was a reminder that “the data that councils might have is much more sensitive, potentially much more controversial”.
He said he had asked Islington’s planning department how it hoped to spend extra income from planning fees, which rise next month. “It was technology rather than people,” he said.
The committee is due to question City Hall’s chief digital officer, the former Camden councillor Theo Blackwell, and planners from Barnet, Lambeth, Ealing and Greenwich about AI next week.