Former Lib Dem councillor Fred Carver says he's ‘unlikely to work for the party again'
Thursday, 16th May 2013
Fred Carver: 'I probably won’t work for them again, but that is more a lifestyle choice. Because it shouldn’t matter: your party is not your football team'
Published: 16 May, 2013
by RICHARD OSLEY
A FORMER Liberal Democrat councillor has told how he is “unlikely to work for the party again” after becoming disillusioned during his time involved in party politics.
Fred Carver, who was the youngest councillor in Camden’s history when he was elected to the Town Hall in the Cantelowes ward aged 21 in 2006, published his thoughts in a long online essay last week, warning that tribal politics undermined serious debate.
Mr Carver, who left the council three years ago, wrote on the Who Rules Where blogsite: “I might vote Lib Dem and I might not (probably not, if it means voting for the coalition) but I reserve the right to pick and choose as I see fit.
"I probably won’t work for them again, but that is more a lifestyle choice. Because it shouldn’t matter: your party is not your football team.”
His piece added: “I suppose this is my letter of resignation from the Liberal Democrats. It is not really.
"I’ve read a fair few letters of resignation from Lib Dems over the last few years and artistically they have been disappointing: many seem somewhat disingenuous – the potter gasping with astonishment that his idol, who he had been working on for some time, does indeed have feet of clay.
"But none have been surprising and all have brought in to the idea that one is either a Lib Dem or one isn’t. I’d like political identities to be fuzzier than that – the way political views are.”
The essay is presented as a window into how he saw Lib Dem organise themselves during his time working on campaigns.
He warned: “Volunteers occupy a position in the Liberal Democrats not unlike that of the ‘Hijira’, or eunuchs, of South Asia.
"On the one hand they are considered the lowest of the low: stupid, surly, and fit only for the most basic manual work.
"On the other, they possess a certain sort of spiritual power which is coveted and must be appeased at all times. Thus contempt is concealed, and even the mightiest minister in the land must make a show of doing the occasional paper round to demonstrate fealty.
"There is a conceit that all Liberal Democrats start off as volunteers. It isn’t true, but those that didn’t fake it as best they can.”
And he added: “Councillors are essentially paid volunteers.
"We also let them run municipal services. Let’s think about that for a moment: imagining you were conducting a Rawlsian experiment to establish the ideal form of Government.
"You might come to the conclusion that a system of justice is vital to contain the worst excesses of rational self-interest. You might come to the conclusion that some sort of basic social safety net is required to maximize the minimum potential regret or loss of wellbeing.
"You would be highly unlikely to determine that it would probably be best if we put the person who delivers the most newspapers in charge of town planning.”
Mr Carver wrote that “most people in political parties never ever talk about politics”, adding: “I have managed campaigns for candidates at very high levels where I can honestly tell you I haven’t the faintest clue what my candidate’s political beliefs were.”
Asked whether he thought the issues he raised were specific to the Lib Dems, Mr Carver, who now works for a charity, said: “I would be stunned if all the other political parties weren’t completely identical.”