Club boss Alex Proud sparks north London vs east London row with ‘Shoreditchification' attack
Thursday, 16th January 2014
Published: 16 January, 2014
By ROISIN O'CONNOR
IT has been the north London vs east London debate rolling across the internet all week, a tit-for-tat spat which has seen claims that Shoreditch is not as cool as the people who go there think it is, and that Camden Town has lost all of its cultural relevance to the city's young trendsetters.
The territorial dispute was sparked off on Monday by club and gallery owner Alex Proud, a star on Channel 4's antique dealing show Four Rooms, who used his new column in the Daily Telegraph to attack the 'Shoreditchification of London' – and at the same time sing the praises of Camden Town's enduring appeal. He insisted NW1 had a "sustainable" culture that had not been matched in east London.
But his column provoked a backlash from the so-called 'hipsters' he was attacking, with a warning that Camden had lost its importance.
Blogger Aleks Eror wrote in a scathing counter-blog for the Telegraph that it was "last culturally relevant in the mid-2000s, when people still read the NME and promoters remembered Razorlight."
Mr Proud told the New Journal that he thought this reaction was "synonymous with the slight air of self-satisfied arrogance found in Shoreditch."
And there was a strong reaction from traders in Camden Market this week, who were quick to defend their patch and support Mr Proud's view.
Sharon Fleming, 55, who works at Fleming Antiques in Camden Lock, said: "After Christmas we had the biggest influx of visitors – you could barely move for the crowds. There's nowhere quite like it for attracting people from all over the world. We get a lot of celebrities who come for a browse – Bob Geldof, a lot of musicians.”
She explained that she used to work as a bunny at the Playboy Club in Park Lane during the 1970's and is therefore used to the kind of casual celebrity appearance that Camden attracts.
“Of course it's still lovely to see them come into the shop,” she said. “I think we make it accessible to everyone – it's not like one of the most expensive antiques places in the West End. And Camden is like that generally.”
Charles Blanchard, 30, moved from Paris two months ago and now works at Viola Viola, a vintage clothes shop in the Stables Market.
“London would miss a market like Camden,” he said. “To suggest that it's not relevant is ridiculous. There's been a market here for over a century and it's still going strong. It's very inspiring to work here. Losing Camden would be like getting rid of the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, it's iconic.”
And Carina Alexandra, 26, who has worked in Camden Market for four years, added: "The people who come here are always interesting, and funny. They come from all over the world. It's the place to work if you don't want to grow up. It's magic – I feel like Peter Pan working here. And it's not just a job either, it's a lifestyle as well.”
She was keen to point out that Camden is one of the few places in London which attracts a diverse range of subcultures all at once.
“The punks, goths, hippies, freaks… everyone who comes here feels comfortable enough to express themselves,” she said. “It's relevant because people still come here after all this time. They still love the atmosphere.”
Raffaele Coronica, originally from Italy, has lived and worked in Camden for a year, currently at he trance music and cyber clothing store Cyberdog, said: "I love the Stables. It's fashionable and innovative but at the same time there's a sense of tradition. I think Camden is one the most unique parts of London – you can be whatever and whoever you want. Anyone who says Camden isn't culturally relevant probably doesn't know Camden very well."
Mr Proud's column has reportedly received around 300,000 hits – the most-viewed article on the Telegraph's website for the day – and has been shared around 37,000 times.
“I think Camden was probably the place they [Shoreditch hipsters] hung around in ten years ago, and now view as passe,” he told the New Journal. “Camden might not be the coolest place in the country right now, but it has a sustainable, established culture quite unlike anywhere else in the country. We have this depth of cultural significance, and more live music on a Monday night than Shoreditch has in a month. Theirs is a shallow, fickle affectation of trendiness. I wouldn't trade Camden for anything. Ich bin ein Camdener.”