UPDATED EVERY FRIDAY
Last Update:
Friday 27th May, 2005
All content © New Journal Enterprises, 2005.
 
 
 

SECTIONS
NEWS
FEATURES
REVIEWS
FORUM
JOHN GULLIVER
 
RECRUITMENT
CONTACT US 
 
NAVIGATION
BROWSE ARCHIVE
 


With Google

by Kim Janssen
Revealed: Scandal of tower block fire traps

Peter Harvey points out some of the ‘fire safety’ features at the Blashford block in Adelaide Road, Swiss Cottage. Abovet: A locked and rusting control switch

locked dry rise main (for pumping water)
a broken fire door
NOT a single tower block in Camden is fullyfitted with fire alarms and smoke detectors, a New Journal investigation has revealed.
As the tragic death of 70-year-old grandmother Irene Linnane in a blaze at her 12th-floor Holborn flat showed last month, thousands of tenants across Camden are at risk from the failure to bring fire safety up to modern standards.
At least four fires in the last 12 months at other Camden high rises have left tenants in need of hospital treatment, although, mercifully, no others have died – yet.
But shockingly, there is no requirement for landlords to fit alarms or smoke detectors at blocks built before 1992; free detectors are only fitted where tenants request them directly from the fire brigade.
Ms Linnane’s daughter, Avril Wood, said: “When I found out there were no fire alarms because the building was too old, it made me mad.
“I can’t believe there would be regulations that didn’t include having fire alarms.”
Today the CNJ calls for the safety measures to be put in place is being backed by the Fire Brigades Union, which also called for sprinkler systems to be fitted at all high rises in a vote at its national conference in Southport.
That call follows the death of two Hertfordshire firefighters in a high-rise blaze and will include a demand that central government pay local authorities for the improvements.
Peter Harvey, chairman of the tenants association at Blashford, an 18-story high-rise on the Chalcots Estate in Adelaide Road, said: “We have no fire alarms or smoke detectors in most of our flats – if there’s a fire they have to go around and knock on each door to get people out, which is crazy.
“The windows still haven’t been fixed from the last fire which was nearly a year ago.
“The fire was outside in the basement but the smoke rose up through the lift shaft and older people a long way up the building had to be hospitalised because of it.
“It was very difficult to get out of the building through the foyer but we managed it. But I’m very concerned about what would happen if there was a fire higher up the building.
“We were promised fire safety improvements through the PFI but that now won’t happen.”
A blaze on the seventh floor of nearby Dorney, also on the Chalcots estate, in October left four people in need of medical attention and led to complaints from tenants about poorly maintained fire doors.
Two infernos at Bacton in Haverstock Road, Gospel Oak, led tenants to complain that vulnerable elderly or drink and drug addicted tenants were unwisely being placed in high-rises. Former tenants chair Ann Atherton said: “We’ve had cameras and a concierge put in recently – they spent all this money but there’s no alarms on the upper floors and we haven’t been given any instructions about the evacuation process.”
An FBU spokesman and Camden firefighter said: “I don’t know of a single tower block in Camden that has fire alarms or smoke detectors fitted in every flat and communal space.
“Fighting fires in a high rise is one of the hardest challenges we face. You are isolated and to a large extent you’re at the mercy of the fire safety measures in place at the building – are the exits clear and have people who could get out, got out.
“Anything that could be done to reduce the risks should be done, particularly because the number of aerial units – fire engines with particularly long ladders – has been cut recently.”
Camden Council, owns 13 tower blocks in Holborn, Mornington Crescent, Swiss Cottage, Gospel Oak and West Hampstead. It points to its ‘safe as houses’ campaign to make tenants aware of the availability of free smoke detectors but says it cannot afford to install complete systems itself.
Government investment in council housing has been on hold since tenants rejected plans to hand over ownership of their flats to a partially privatised ‘Almo’ board in January last year.
And a Private Finance Initiative bid, which would have unlocked funds for improvements at five tower blocks on the Chalcots Estate in Swiss Cottage, was rejected by the Government in February.
Housing Supremo Cllr Raj Chada said: “It’s important that people know that if they want a smoke alarm it will be provided to them by the fire service. Obviously we are pushing generally for extra investment in housing whilst work with ‘safe as houses’ continues.”
Camden Council and the Fire Brigade said, in a joint statement: “We have been working together over the past two years under the ‘Safe as Houses’ project to give free fire safety checks and smoke alarms to all residents.
“So far, around 5,500 residents have taken up the offer and had a smoke alarm installed as a direct result of this project.”

Free fire safety checks can be organised by calling 0800 028 4428.