|
A threat to the British way of life
|
An exhitbition reveals there is nothing new about stirring
up hatred over strangers, writes Frank Dobson
|


Frank Dobson and Sir Trevor MacDonald at the exhibition.
Above and below, two of the collections exhibits

|
IT'S often said there is nothing new under the sun. When it
comes to stirring up hatred against strangers, that is certainly
true.
Whether you believe me or not, I suggest you visit the special
exhibition at the Jewish Museum in Albert Street.
Entitled Closing the Door? Immigrants to Britain 1905-2005, it
details a century of anti-immigrant campaigns and law making.
It sets out the arguments used by the prejudice mongers in every
decade, ranging from attacks on Jews and other refugees from eastern
Europe 100 years ago to asylum seekers today. And it spells out
the words they have used.
Virtually every bigoted phrase, every intolerant argument has
been recycled again and again. The incomers are almost always
portrayed as destitute, idle, disease-ridden and a threat to the
British way of life.
There is a board in the exhibition with a century of noxious quotations
from newspapers, politicians and demagogues.
What they say is the same. Its only who said it and when
they said it that changes.
Today, virtually everybody accepts that it was right for Britain
to take refugees from Nazi Germany. But that wasnt the accepted
view at the time. So thousands went to their deaths because they
did not qualify as refugees to Britain in the 1930s.
We have to learn that its no good being kind and principled
after the event. Its now that counts. I dont know
any decent people who want to send the persecuted back to torture
and death, even when the British National Party, and people who
should know better, are ranting on about asylum seekers.
The fact is that some asylum seekers think they are entitled to
refugee status and they are. Others genuinely believe they are
entitled but are not. Some others are just trying to fiddle the
system.
But its better for everybody if their applications are dealt
with humanely and promptly.
Its also right to work for a better world so far fewer need
to seek refuge.
In any case, as the exhibition shows, asylum seekers are only
a minority of people coming to Britain. Many others come here
to study or to work. Some intend to stay while others expect to
be here for only a year or two.
And, of course, many British citizens go to study or work abroad.
We all benefit from the two-way flow. Indeed, we owe some very
British institutions to refugees and immigrants. The first fish
and chip shop was opened by a Jewish immigrant in 1860.
Meals on wheels were pioneered by an Indian doctor in Battersea.
Britains most successful car the Mini was
designed by a Turkish-born Greek. Britains most famous heart
surgeon was born in Egypt. TVs most popular newsreader was
born in Trinidad.
Wherever we go and whatever we do we depend on people who were
once strangers to this land or on their descendants. Just think
of the buses, corner shops, restaurants, take-aways, doctors and
nurses and midwives, mathematicians and scientists.
And, of course, most of us or our ancestors were strangers in
our time. Nearly every group when they first arrived were the
target of bigotry over religion, national origin or race. Rampant
prejudice against Catholics has been followed by rampant prejudice
against Muslims. Notices saying No Irish disappeared
and for a time were replaced by No Blacks.
Sadly as some people begin to feel more established, they start
pointing the finger at later arrivals. It doesnt make any
difference. The nasties dont drop one hatred to make room
for another, they just add the latest to the list.
Most of us find comfort in familiar surroundings and are attached
to the place we call home.
So it takes a lot to make anybody uproot themselves and their
family and move to another country.
Some are driven out by fear. Others are attracted to what seems
to them a good place. That is a compliment to Britains reputation
and prosperity.
In my experience of advice services over 25 years, very few people
who come to Camden come to sponge.
A few do but most of them are desperate for a job. One Friday
evening at Camden Town Hall, no fewer than four highly-qualified
doctors came seeking my help to get them work in the NHS.
It would have cost the taxpayer £1 million to train them
here. We were getting them for free.
So, I strongly recommend a visit to the Jewish Museum whatever
your race, religion or national origin. Its a reminder of
the evils that flow from bigotry.
The exhibition runs until August 21. Call 020 7284 1997
for details.
Frank Dobson is the Labour MP for Holborn and St Pancras.
|