|
One Week with John Gulliver
|
|
Why cant we get the facts Mr Benn?
|
|

Hilary Benn
|
I FEEL the excitement of the chase as this column closes in
on cabinet minister Hilary Benn aided and abetted by two readers
who are also dogging his steps.
Mr Benn (pictured) is accused of neglecting to the point
of indifference the scores, if not hundreds, of children
who have lost arms and legs in bombing raids in the early days
of the Iraq war.
Their plight was highlighted by a former New Journal reporter,
Lee Gordon, who brought a little girl, Zeynab, over from Iraq
to get her fitted with an artificial leg.
In a recent visit to the British zone in and near Basra he saw
children in villages who had lost their legs, still hobbling painfully
on crutches. Nothing much had changed since he saw them a year
ago.
Two weeks ago Hampstead MP Glenda Jackson tabled a question in
the Commons asking Mr Benn what his department for international
development was doing to provide medical assistance for these
tragic children.
A reader, Nicholas Woods of South Hill Park Gardens, Hampstead
following our story about these children in this column
had asked the MP to question Mr Benn about them.
But in his written reply (see page 6) it seems everything possible
is being done for them.
But is it? Mr Woods saw one gaping omission in Mr Benns
reply it didnt contain one single figure about amputees.
After reading it we still dont know how many children were
maimed in bombing raids. Nor how many children have been fitted
with prosthetic limbs.
There are figures galore about how much money is being spent on
medical assistance through the International Committee of the
Red Cross and Unicef but Mr Benn, I ask, why cannot you
give us just a few hard facts.
Mr Woods seemed to share my amazement at Mr Benns dodgy
reply. After a forensic dissection of his one page response, Mr
Woods drew up two pages of questions for Ms Jackson to put to
Anne Clwyd, the governments Humanitarian Envoy in Iraq to
match Mr Benns answer.
He has also involved ex-cabinet minister Clare Short by sending
her copy of his letter.
Meanwhile, another reader Clem Alford of Tavistock Place, Bloomsbury,
has also fired off letters about our campaign to Mr Benn, Anne
Clwyd and Tony Blair.
A reply from Aemer Lodhi, who works in Blairs Direct
Communication Unit, pointed out that the PM hoped Mr Alford
understood this was a matter for the Foreign and Commonwealth
Office and so his letter had been forwarded on.
Mr Alford describes this as passing the buck. That
couldnt have been better put.
Tim reads between the lines
|

Tim Coates
|
PRAISE was heaped on Tim Coates, former managing editor of
Waterstones, by the Parliamentary select committee on Britains
libraries.
The august body came to the same conclusion as Mr Coates in his
report for the charity Libri that libraries were amply funded
but managers were failing to buy enough books.
Mr Coates, who lives in Fortune Green, has been arguing along
these lines for sometime.
It turns out that of £1 billion spent on libraries only
eight per cent is used to fill the shelves. And who are the worst
boroughs in Britain? Camden and Islington. They spend only 4 per
cent of their budget on books.
Rock crawls back to Camden in beery style
|

Pictured above: The Gliterati and inset Graham Coxon
|
MUSIC is the food of love, they say, but the Camden Crawl
on Thursday night proved beyond doubt that beer is the drink of
music.
More than 4,200 music fans crammed into Camden Towns world
famous live music venues for the tenth anniversary of the boozy
festival.
The Crawl gave early exposure to world famous acts including Moby
and Beth Orton when it began in 1995, but was absent for seven
years before its welcome return this year.
For £15 fans could buy a wristband that allowed them access
to ten venues from Barfly in Chalk Farm down to Club Koko in Mornington
Crescent, with 40 bands playing from 6pm until the early hours
of Friday.
Local boy Graham Coxon and punk legends The Buzzcocks shared the
bill with lesser known bands.
I dont know whether it was all the beer or the informal
come-and-go-as-you-please set up, but there was a real sense of
bonhomie among the revellers something all too often lacking
from todays music scene.
Police, who, fearing trouble, had banned late licences for many
of the venues, said they had no problems all night.
Fight the good fight

From left: Sarah Walker, Jenny Hautman, Selma James, Sue Webster
(front centre) Christel Amissm Michael Kalmanovitz and Phoebe
Jones |
THE wife of a US soldier who refuses to fight in Iraq, Sue
Webster, called for the release of her husband Abdullah in Camden
on Saturday.
Mrs Webster, a secondary-school teacher from Birmingham, has been
campaigning for her husbands release since he was jailed
for 14 months last year for refusing to fight in Iraq.
Speaking on a platform organised by campaign groups Payday and
Global Womens Strike at the Trinity United Reform Church
in Buck Street, Camden Town, she said: The court martial
said he had refused to kill other Muslims but that is not true
he refused to fight because the war was illegal.
She added there had been tacit sympathy for her husbands
stance amongst his fellow soldiers in the Engineers Battalion,
but that they were too frightened to speak out.
Abdullah had served for 20 years, including stints in Kosovo and
Iraq in the first Gulf War, but has been stripped of his pension
and is currently in a military jail in the US.
Pure poetry from Sir Bob
IN his usual intellectual style, Bob Geldof (pictured) displayed
his love of Keats and Shelley at the British Library on Monday
by likening them to rock stars.
After a reading of the poets he told me: They were rock
stars. They all died young, they were all about politics, passion
and girls. They were trying to get laid, not having much luck.
Talking of rock stars, actor Tom Hollander brought to my attention
a classical precursor to what has always seemed to me the most
awkward rhyme in pop. I think it was Johnny Rotten of the Sex
Pistols who once screamed: I am an antichrist, I am an anarchist.
Yet Shelley was happy to use a similar rhyme in his masterpiece
The Mask of Anarchy, a stanza from which runs:
And each dweller,
panic-stricken,
Felt his heart
with terror sicken
Hearing the
tempestuous cry
Of the triumph
of Anarchy.
Thats rich!
SCHOOLBOY Marley Morris caught a slight whiff of republicanism
when he asked the Commonwealth Secretary General Don McKinnon
on Monday a question about the Queen.
Marley, aged 15, a pupil at Haverstock School, wanted to know
whether it was hypocritical that the Commonwealth working to reduce
the gap between the rich and the poor is headed by the Queen.
Why? Because shes the richest woman in the world?
replied Mr McKinnon who was visiting the school on Commonwealth
Day. He added: Her role is really as a figurehead
its symbolic. It is an anachronism, but on the other hand
its not giving us any problems.

|